But this is precisely the construction and engineering proposition made by the David Ball Group and its PUDLO range of BBA approved admixtures for waterproofing, strengthening and extending the life of concrete.
The case for using PUDLO for Building E at Merchant Square proved more than water-tight for the foundation services specialist, Expanded Structures Ltd, part of Laing O’Rourke.
Above ground, it provides office space and ground floor retail, with a heatlth club and car park facility in the 75m by 55m plan basement.
Guarantee
PUDLO modified concrete carries a 20 year insurance-backed completed project guarantee, effectively assuring performance and workmanship for the same period.
Crucial to this guarantee is the comprehensive service support provided by PUDLO Site Support Team inspectors. The use of PUDLO admixtures is project-managed by these experienced technicians who provide quality control of the application, from concrete design, batching and mixing, to site preparation, pouring, and post-cure.
Building E required a critical standard of waterproofing, incorporating both lift pits and a swimming pool three levels down.
Intrinsic
PUDLO waterproofing is intrinsic to the concrete, eliminating the time, labour, deliveries and additional equipment involved in laying a waterproof membrane.
The basement construction would have involved cutting and fitting membrane material around numerous pile caps and drainage pop-ups, leading to genuine concerns about creating possible areas of weakness.
Space was restricted, so eliminating the installation of a membrane eased the complex logistics of managing the basement programme. Plant and equipment could track around freely without risk of damage to the material. Just a piece of rebar, if dropped, can tear membrane material, resulting in a water path and potentially defects in time.
Simplicity
The final design called for substitution of all of the membrane in the basement slab with PUDLO, based on the simplicity of using one system and the benefits of the guarantee.
In addition to supplying materials, PUDLO’s service is reassuring for specifiers and clients alike. It includes close attention to the concrete mix and specification details, as well as site inspections, attending the pour, and taking on the responsibility for achieving an effective installation.
PUDLO’s proven performance worldwide coupled with the on-site service and back-up, provided justification and peace of mind for selecting PUDLO as the waterproofing solution throughout the project.
Strength
Although PUDLO was used primarily for its waterproofing properties, its strength characteristics provided an added reassurance.
As well as lining and filling pores, PUDLO alters the micro-structure of concrete to provide significantly increased factors of dimensional stability, waterproofing and strength. It provides over 20 times greater water impermeability than the next best competing waterproofing additive, and improved 7 and 28 day concrete strengths by almost 50%.
Pouring conditions were difficult in some areas, with concrete being pumped over 100m through twists and turns and down several levels. But thanks to PUDLO’s fast-forming strength properties, as well as its excellent workability, texture, plasticity and flow characteristics, early access was gained onto the slab.
Top-Down
As well as incorporating some of the largest floorplates in the West End, building E at Merchant Square has used ‘top-down’ construction.
This involved a slightly different progression of structural detail. PUDLO’s site support team worked with the contractor and ready mix concrete supplier to ensure that the design detail of the concrete mix and delivery schedule worked with the construction programme.
Firstly, the ground floor slab was constructed over the fully secanted piled basement. With the piles having the capacity to hold at that height, a 10m wide ring slab was constructed around the perimeter to act as a propping slab giving temporary support to the secant until construction could be tied into the ground floor. Effectively, it creates a solid box around basement construction.
Top-down construction was preferred because traditional construction would have involved a mass of sacrificial propping. By putting in the concrete slab, progress was made simultaneously above and below, and the slab was retained as a structure, resulting in less wastage.
The sequence of construction involved completion of the pile caps to the three lift and stair cores first, so work on these could progress to upper levels while basement work got underway. As a result, the cores were completed about the same time as the basement.
Building E is due to be complete in 2009, as part of first phase construction at Merchant Square, with full scheme completion in 2012.